Jump to Navigation

2008 Platform (filtered to anti-homosexual crusade)

This is a plank-by-plank review of the 2008 platform. Use the links at right to narrow it down, or explore alternate views:

Show:
original version
proposed changes
improved version
Showing only planks with anti-homosexual crusade fault: The GOP should not be a virulent, anti-homosexual crusade. (show all planks)
Legend: text to be added text to be deleted

Homosexuality

Strengthening Families, Protecting Life and Promoting Health > Celebrating Traditional Marriage > Homosexuality
We believe that the practice of homosexuality tears at the fabric of society, contributes to the breakdown of the family unit, and leads to the spread of dangerous, communicable diseases. Homosexual behavior is contrary to the fundamental, unchanging truths that have been ordained by God, recognized by our country's founders, and shared by the majority of Texans. Homosexuality must not be presented as an acceptable "alternative" lifestyle in our public education and policy, nor should "family" be redefined to include homosexual "couples." We are opposed to any granting of special legal entitlements, refuse to recognize, or grant special privileges including, but not limited to: marriage between persons of the same sex (regardless of state of origin), custody of children by homosexuals, homosexual partner insurance or retirement benefits. We oppose any criminal or civil penalties against those who oppose homosexuality out of faith, conviction, or belief in traditional values

Homosexual acceptance is increasing in America, even among conservatives and Christians. An anti-gay crusade cannot help the Republican's relevance to society.

That being said, many thoughtful people see homosexuality as a personally destructive lifestyle choice. While government's job is not to decide morality or affirm either viewpoint, it must fully affirm one's right to hold and express their chosen viewpoint. Furthermore, conservatives support the Constitutional right to free association, which in part means sectarian and noncommercial movements have a right to define their own moral codes that may prevent their association with what they view as improper moral choices.

Marriage is handled in a different plank, and the courts have been clear about our constitutional right to free association.

Texas Sodomy Statutes

Strengthening Families, Protecting Life and Promoting Health > Celebrating Traditional Marriage > Texas Sodomy Statutes
We oppose the legalization of sodomy. We demand that Congress exercise its authority granted by the U.S. Constitution to withhold jurisdiction from the federal courts from cases involving sodomy.
(plank deleted)

Regulation of private bedroom behavior on moral grounds is government expansionism.

Child Support and Visitation

Strengthening Families, Protecting Life and Promoting Health > Protecting Our Children > Child Support and Visitation
We support equity between responsible parents in child support, custody, and visitation rights and costs, as well as the strengthening of laws designed to protect children from abuse. No parent/grandparentone should be denied court ordered visitation, because because of jurisdictional disputes between states. We also believe that no homosexual or any individual convicted of child abuse or molestation should have the right to custody or adoption of a minor child, and that visitation with minor children by such persons should, if allowed, should be prohibited but if ordered by the court limited to supervised periods.

Child abuse is a separate topic.

It is unconscionable to lump homosexuals with child molesters and abusers.

Adoption

Strengthening Families, Protecting Life and Promoting Health > Protecting Our Children > Adoption
We support reducing the time, bureaucratic interference, and cost of adoption. We oppose mandatory open adoption.We support reducing the time, bureaucratic interference and cost of adoption. The law should assure mothers of a choice in selecting a traditional home for their children at the time of terminating their rights for adoption. We oppose mandatory open adoption and adoption by homosexuals.

This plank freely creates more mandates to regulate private matters, just like Democrats.

The amount of involvement a parent has in the adoption process should be up to the adoption facility.

The kinds of parents allowed to adopt is a matter for the adoption agency and the biological parent, not for the state.

Americans with Disabilities Act

Strengthening Families, Protecting Life and Promoting Health > Empowering Families to Direct Their Health Care > Americans with Disabilities Act
We support amendment of the Americans with Disabilities Act to exclude from its definition those persons with infectious diseases, substance addiction, learning disabilities, behavior disorders, homosexual practices and, and mental stress, thereby reducing abuse of the Act.

The mention of homosexuals is mean-spirited.

Support of Our Armed Forces

Restoring American Sovereignty and Leadership > Domestic > Support of Our Armed Forces
We support the armed forces. We recommend modernizing and maintaining the equipment and weapons for the safety and effectiveness of our armed forces. While we support a continued policy of an overwhelmingly strong military, we also support fiscal sanity: we demand termination of wasteful or ineffective equipment and weapons programs. We demand that displaced military personnel have their votes counted. We support construction of a Texas veterans museum.We encourage all Americans to support the brave and patriotic men and women of our armed forces. They should be paid a wage sufficient to prevent them from ever needing food stamps and that encourages retention. We strongly recommend that all our armed forces remain commanded only by the Commander-in-Chief and his subordinate commanders; upgrading, modernizing and maintaining the equipment, weapons, and vehicles for the safety, efficiency and effectiveness of our armed forces; the continuation of the all volunteer armed forces, the recruitment and advancement of military personnel based on the needs of the military and the qualifications of the person; disqualification of homosexuals from military service; immediate discharge of HIV positive individuals; separation of men and women in basic training; exclusion of women from ground and submarine combat roles; provision of full military honors for burial of veterans; restoration of all veteran benefits without an offset for disability pay; health and disability benefits equal to active military for national guard and reserves; passage of a "new" G.I Bill that fully funds expanded educational scholarship opportunities for honorably separated Veterans; restoration of full lifetime health benefits to retired military and their families; and assurance that military and civilian voters displaced by their service be afforded full opportunity for their votes to be counted; and the expeditious construction of a Veterans Museum in Texas.

This is a terrible, unfocused plank that is a grab bag of random wishes and left-wing government expansionism.

Wages are an economic issue in every industry, including the military. If wages are too low, they will show up in poor recruitment and retention numbers. Given good recruiting numbers, there is little evidence of insufficient wages.

There is no credible movement to:

  • Reassign commandment of the armed forces away from the President.
  • Move away from a volunteer force.
  • Recruit to fill ranks with unqualified people.

The issue of women in combat roles is an internal issue for the military and does not deserve mention here. If it comes down to it, women may decline to serve in the military if they do not want a combat role.

These are in fact left-wing and remarkably expensive policies:

  • Removing disability pay offset: A lack of an offset for other disability pay is unfair: you collect twice for one disability!
  • Full health benefits for National Guard and reservists: U.S. health benefits are typically a function of employment. National Guard and reservists do not work when they are not on duty, so it makes little sense to extend health coverage to off-duty times.
  • Lifetime health benefits: Just like with any other employer-sponsored health plan, military health plan should terminate upon end of employment.

It is counterproductive and pointless to have a witch hunt for homosexuals.

There is zero evidence that the military is mishandling HIV.

Separation of men and women in basic training is counterproductive. They will have to work together in the field. Why create artificial barriers?

The G.I. Bill provision is accomplished. The current bill pays up to $47,556 in educational benefits over a maximum of 36 months.

This plank is wordy. For example:

  • "Upgrading" and "modernizing" are the same thing.
  • Vehicles are a type of equipment.
  • Something that is safe and efficient is also effective.